This feature is not on the App Store yet. The current version there is Finance Bay 4.4.1, and it has none of what this post describes. This is a development update about work that is built and in testing. It will arrive in a later update, and I am not promising a date.
Finance Bay Pro already lets you put a benchmark on an account chart. You pick a ticker, and the app mirrors your own trades into it. The line shows where the same money, put in on the same days, would be if it had gone into that ticker instead.
The problem with a price line
Today that benchmark line follows the price of the ticker, and a price leaves dividends out. A fund such as SPY pays them every quarter. The dividends your own holdings paid are part of your account, so the chart compares your return with dividends to a benchmark without them. That makes you look better than you did.
The gap grows with time. In my test, one deposit into SPY on 3 November 2021 was worth 6.9 percent more on 5 November 2026 with the dividends reinvested than the price line showed.
What is coming
- A Dividends reinvested switch on each benchmark. Turn it on and the line becomes a total return: every dividend the benchmark paid buys more of it. The switch is off by default, so a benchmark you already have stays as it is until you change it.
- Three indexes in one tap. The benchmark sheet gets an Indexes section with the S&P 500, the Dow Jones Industrial Average and the Russell 2000. Each one is the index itself, not a fund that follows it, and each is quoted in dollars.
Good to know
- An index pays no dividends. For a total return comparison with the S&P 500, add a fund that follows it, such as SPY, and turn the switch on. Use the index when you want the plain price level that the news quotes.
- Dollar indexes only. Indexes in other currencies, such as the DAX, are not built.
- Still part of Pro, on iPhone, iPad and Mac. Adding a benchmark needs Finance Bay Pro today, and that does not change.
When you can use it
Not yet. The App Store version is 4.4.1, and this ships in an update after it. When it is live, the release post on this blog will say so.
Until then, tell me what you want from benchmarks: which indexes are missing, and which comparison you run most. Write to support@financebay.app or post on r/financebay.